Assessing a new manuscript


Here are some of the key things to look out for in a new submission.

1. Do you have a competing interest that prevents you from handling the manuscript?
If you have a competing interest with the manuscript or someone on the author list, please declare this to the Editorial Office when first assigned and the manuscript will be reassigned. More information on identifying competing interests can be found in our editorial policies.

2. Does the manuscript appear sufficiently sound to proceed to peer review?
If not, please provide comments to the authors to explain your decision to reject without peer review. If you feel that a manuscript could be revised to address your concerns then you can request that the authors revise the manuscript before sending for peer review.

3. Is the submission within the scope of your journal?
The full scope for the journal can be viewed on your journal's 'About' page. 

If a manuscript is deemed out of scope but still scientifically valid, upon rejection it will usually be sent to the Journal Transfer, where our editorial staff will reach out to the author and try to find a more suitable journal for it, or sometimes you can select to transfer to a specific alternative journal.

4. Is the article type correct for the content?
You can view the article types available for your journal within its submission guidelines.

5. Does the manuscript adhere to the journal’s editorial policies?
All manuscripts must adhere to Editorial policies. If you have any concerns with a manuscript, please discuss this with your journal contact or inform the Editorial Office (or email to: and we can investigate this further.

The following points in particular should be considered prior to sending a manuscript for peer review:

  • Do you perceive any ethical problems with the manuscript?
  • Does the manuscript include consent if any data relating to individual patients is included?
  • Does the manuscript adhere to relevant standards for deposition of data and reporting?
  • If the manuscript reports the results of a clinical trial does the manuscript include a Trial Registration Number?
  • Are there any concerns with plagiarism or duplicate publication?

6. Does the quality of the English Language affect your ability to assess the scientific content?
If you receive a new manuscript that requires English copy editing before you can sufficiently assess the scientific content, this can be requested from the authors as a pre-review revision.

If you are unsure on any of the points above, please get in touch with managing editor ( or editor-in-chief ( who will be able to provide further information specific to your journal.


Copyright 2014-2024 Biomedpress. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. A partner of Crossref.

Follow us: